Hello dear
Welcome To Mystic Market LBI
Mystic Market LBI began as Mystic Lobster Roll Co. and has evolved into a premier destination for sandwich lovers in Ship Bottom, NJ. This women-owned establishment specializes in delectable sandwiches, including the famed Jersey Devil and mouthwatering lobster rolls. Guests are welcomed with accessible amenities, patio dining, and a commitment to sustainability with plastic-free packaging. Diners rave about the freshness and quality of the ingredients, making it a beloved local spot. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or catering an event, Mystic Market LBI ensures a delightful experience, embodying the essence of coastal flavors and warm hospitality.
About
Mystic Market LBI
Welcome to Mystic Market LBI, a delightful culinary gem located at 2901 Long Beach Blvd in Ship Bottom, NJ. Known for its exquisite sandwiches and seafood offerings, Mystic Market LBI promises a fresh and vibrant dining experience that is hard to forget. With a focus on high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients, this market not only satisfies your cravings but also elevates your beachside meals.
Among the highlight dishes, the lobster rolls have received rave reviews, hailed as some of the best outside of Cape Cod. Whether you opt for the Maine or Connecticut style, customers can’t get enough of the rich, creamy lobster bisque that accompanies these sandwiches. Many have commented on the generous portions of succulent lobster nestled in buttered, warm bread—proof that Mystic Market knows how to treat seafood lovers right.
- Lobster Rolls: An essential must-try for any visitor, featuring ample lobster meat complemented by a side helping of their delicious lobster bisque.
- Sandwich Variety: From Jersey Devil sandwiches to Pork Roll Egg Cheese, there’s something for every palate. The portions are sizable enough to share with friends after a day at the beach.
- Fresh Ingredients: Customers rave about the freshness of their salads and accompaniments, spotlighting avocados, roasted red peppers, and their celebrated white mac and cheese.
The ambiance at Mystic Market LBI is as inviting as the food. Gleaming clean interiors paired with friendly staff create an atmosphere perfect for a quick bite or a leisurely meal with family and friends. Many patrons, like Sandy, commended the employees’ patience and kindness, especially when curating meals for special occasions. This attention to customer service enhances the overall experience, distinguishing Mystic Market from typical sandwich shops.
If you're in the area, make sure to stop by Mystic Market LBI for a taste of their incredible offerings. Whether it’s the smoky, satisfying tacos or the classic hot dogs paired with fries, your dining adventure at this market will surely leave you with fond memories and a desire to return. As one satisfied customer put it, “Wonderful experience and I highly highly recommend them!” Discover the flavors of the coastal cuisine and bring home a taste of LBI!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ This place is so good oh my god. My bf and I got two lobster rolls Maine and Connecticut to share and some lobster bisque. The soup was so creamy and delicious, and the rolls were SO amazing. There was an option to get extra lobster meat on your sandwich but its not even needed!! There was plenty of meat on our rolls, and the bread itself was warmed and perfectly buttered and soft. Used to be Mystic Lobster Roll Co., but they moved locations and are now a market as well! Products look nice and fresh. Take it from us were picky with our lobster rolls! Haha Def give this place a try!!!!!! ”
“ Best lobster roll this side of Cape Cod, hands down. Ive tried all the lobster roll franchises, trucks, you name it looking for a real New England lobster roll in NJ, and nothing hit the mark till I found my nirvana at Mystic. Absolute perfection. ”
“ Jersey Devil, BEC, and Pork roll egg cheese were all AMAZING!!!! Cannot wait to go back. ”
“ A huge shoutout and THANK YOU to Mystic Market in Ship Bottom for not only their patience with answering all of my questions about ordering food for our daughters surprise engagement party but also for how wonderful everything was. There were rave reviews about the delicious subs and the chicken tenders. And the shrimp! Such quality and great size! On a side note, when we opened the salad, I was expecting a garden salad. I was so surprised to find this beautiful salad that included avocado and roasted red pepper which we love. Plus, white Mac and Cheese is our favorite so another big hit! Mystic made the entire process from start to finish seamless my husband said pickup was a breeze and the employees were so kind! Thank you again for helping us make our already perfect day that much better. We will be back! ”
“ Everyone was extremely nice. Place is very clean and the food is amazing! We got 3 10 Italian subs and it was big enough to feed 6 people for lunch on the beach. They also have fresh butchered meat and seafood! Perfect place to get what you need to make a surf and turf grilling experience! The even have lobster rolls, and theyre reasonably priced compared to other places in the area! We will certainly be coming back here when were in the area again! Wonderful experience and I highly highly recommend them! ”
“ if youre not ordering the jersey devil when you go YOU ARE MISSING OUT! Mystic meat and seafood has the BEST BREAKFAST sandwiches on the island and the price..... is amazing for the size of the sandwich you receive . 10 slices of bacon on 1 sandwich ”
“ Our first experience at Mystic Market. Best lobsters rolls!! I had the LBI lobster roll with avocado. My husband had a Southern heat lobster roll with candied jalapenos and chipotle. I think Coleslaw, as well was as good as my homemade coleslaw! We will be back! ”
“ What a freakin sandwich! Great bread, Thumans Deli Meat, tons of topping choices fresh and absolutely delish. This place is my new go to lunch spot. Its a Fatmans dream! ”